| Address | Price | Bed / Bths | Interior Space | $sf | WF / Pool | MLS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2830 BAY SHORE CIRCLE |
$2,000,000 | 6/5 |
4,512sf | $443 | N / N | A4665647 |
| 941 VIRGINIA DRIVE |
$1,500,000 | 6/4 |
3,493sf | $429 | N / Y | A4673463 |
Bay Haven Homes for Sale | Luxury Real Estate in Sarasota
Discover Bay Haven Sarasota
Bay Haven is a hidden gem among Sarasota’s prestigious West of the Trail neighborhoods, offering residents a perfect blend of classic coastal living and convenient proximity to downtown Sarasota. Nestled along the picturesque Sarasota Bay, Bay Haven combines timeless Florida architecture, serene tree-lined streets, and an enviable location near the city’s best cultural and recreational attractions. This waterfront enclave embodies the relaxed sophistication that defines Sarasota’s luxury lifestyle.
Bay Haven Real Estate Overview
Real estate in Bay Haven reflects the area’s rich history and evolving architectural character. Many homes date back to the early to mid-20th century and have been beautifully restored, maintaining their original charm while incorporating contemporary upgrades. From charming bungalows and ranch-style homes to expansive waterfront estates and new luxury builds, Bay Haven offers a diverse selection of properties that cater to discerning buyers.
Waterfront residences often include private docks, boat lifts, and sweeping views of Sarasota Bay — ideal for boating enthusiasts who want direct access to the Gulf of Mexico. The community’s inland streets feature well-maintained homes surrounded by mature landscaping, creating a peaceful residential atmosphere while remaining minutes from downtown Sarasota’s dining, shopping, and entertainment scene.
Prime Location and Lifestyle
Located just north of downtown and adjacent to the historic Indian Beach–Sapphire Shores area, Bay Haven is ideally positioned for those who value both tranquility and accessibility. Residents enjoy quick access to the Ringling Museum of Art, St. Armands Circle, and Lido Key Beach, all while being only a short drive to Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport. This proximity makes Bay Haven especially appealing for seasonal residents and professionals seeking convenience without sacrificing peace and privacy.
The neighborhood’s walkable streets and friendly community feel give it a true sense of place. Residents can stroll to nearby parks, enjoy evening sunsets over the bay, or take a quick drive into downtown Sarasota for fine dining and live entertainment. The area also benefits from its closeness to top-rated schools and major medical centers, making it ideal for families and retirees alike.
Architectural Character and Home Design
The homes in Bay Haven showcase Sarasota’s architectural diversity. Classic Florida ranches and mid-century modern designs sit harmoniously alongside contemporary coastal residences and Mediterranean-inspired villas. New construction homes often feature open layouts, designer finishes, and energy-efficient technology, while historic properties retain original details like terrazzo floors, cypress beams, and spacious verandas that reflect the neighborhood’s coastal heritage.
Many homeowners in Bay Haven take pride in maintaining lush tropical landscaping and elegant curb appeal, giving the entire community a refined yet welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re drawn to the character of a restored cottage or the clean lines of a modern bayfront masterpiece, Bay Haven offers an array of options suited to every lifestyle.
Why Buyers Choose Bay Haven
Homebuyers are drawn to Bay Haven for its unbeatable combination of location, charm, and waterfront accessibility. Its West of Trail setting means you’re never far from Sarasota’s most desirable amenities — the downtown arts district, Marina Jack, and Siesta Key Beach are all within easy reach. Yet, the neighborhood maintains a quiet, residential ambiance that feels worlds away from the bustle of city life.
Bay Haven also appeals to those seeking long-term investment potential. The area’s limited inventory and growing demand for waterfront property have contributed to consistent appreciation over time. Homes here are highly sought after, particularly those offering bay views or boating access, making Bay Haven a solid choice for both homeowners and investors alike.
Nearby Attractions and Lifestyle Highlights
Ringling Museum of Art: Just minutes away, this cultural landmark offers world-class art exhibits, performances, and beautifully landscaped grounds overlooking the bay.
Downtown Sarasota: Residents enjoy quick access to fine dining, boutique shopping, and entertainment venues, including the Sarasota Opera and Florida Studio Theatre.
St. Armands Circle: A short drive away, this iconic shopping and dining destination is perfect for weekend strolls and evening dinners by the water.
Lido Key and Longboat Key Beaches: Bay Haven’s location provides easy access to Sarasota’s pristine barrier islands, offering sun-soaked beaches and year-round recreation.
Investment and Real Estate Outlook
Bay Haven’s location and limited availability of waterfront homes ensure that the neighborhood remains one of Sarasota’s most stable and prestigious markets. Demand is consistently strong, and homes rarely remain on the market for long. Whether you’re searching for a primary residence, vacation getaway, or an investment property, Bay Haven delivers enduring appeal and long-term value.
Experience Bay Haven Sarasota
Bay Haven embodies the essence of Sarasota living — a peaceful waterfront community just minutes from the cultural heart of the city. With its historic charm, architectural diversity, and unbeatable location West of Trail, Bay Haven offers an exceptional lifestyle for those seeking both luxury and authenticity. Explore the opportunities that await in Bay Haven Sarasota and discover why this waterfront enclave remains one of the city’s most treasured residential communities.
For more information about homes in Bay Haven Sarasota, contact me at 941.281.5472 or email lisa@sarasotaluxurycondos.com.
