Discover Casey Key & Nokomis: Exclusive Gulf Coast Paradise

Stretching along Florida’s Gulf Coast just south of Venice, Casey Key and the nearby town of Nokomis offer some of the most serene and desirable real estate in Sarasota County. Known for pristine beaches, lush tropical landscaping, and a tranquil island lifestyle, this area blends luxury living with coastal charm. Residents enjoy private beachfront estates, canal-front properties, and an unhurried lifestyle just minutes from downtown Sarasota and the amenities of Southwest Florida’s Gulf Coast.

Casey Key & Nokomis Real Estate Overview

The real estate market on Casey Key and Nokomis is highly coveted, offering a range of properties for discerning buyers. From Gulf-front estates with private docks to waterfront homes on protected canals, each property emphasizes privacy, elegance, and indoor-outdoor coastal living.

  • Gulf-Front Estates: Casey Key features exclusive beachfront mansions with panoramic Gulf views, private pools, and direct beach access.
  • Canal-Front Homes: Many Nokomis properties provide private docks, deep-water access, and seamless boating to Sarasota Bay and the Intracoastal Waterway.
  • Condos & Villas: Boutique complexes and luxury condominiums in Nokomis offer lock-and-leave convenience and resort-style amenities.
  • Investment Properties: Limited availability and high seasonal demand make Casey Key and Nokomis ideal for vacation rentals and long-term investment.

Why Buy in Casey Key & Nokomis?

1. Stunning Beaches & Coastal Scenery: Casey Key offers some of Florida’s most unspoiled beaches, with soft sand, turquoise waters, and seclusion from the crowds. Nokomis Beach provides family-friendly access and easy proximity to local dining and parks.

2. Tranquil Island Lifestyle: Residents enjoy privacy, calm streets, and lush landscaping while remaining close to Sarasota’s cultural, shopping, and dining options.

3. Outdoor Recreation & Boating: With direct Gulf and Intracoastal access, residents can sail, fish, paddleboard, or kayak, while cyclists and walkers enjoy scenic paths along Casey Key and Nokomis’ waterways.

4. Community & Safety: A tight-knit community ensures a welcoming environment, ideal for families, retirees, and seasonal homeowners seeking a secure, relaxed lifestyle.

5. Proximity to Sarasota & Venice: Just a short drive to downtown Sarasota and Venice, residents enjoy award-winning beaches, fine dining, arts, and cultural attractions while maintaining the seclusion of island living.

Local Attractions & Lifestyle Amenities

Beaches & Parks: Casey Key Beach offers private access and world-class Gulf views. Nokomis Beach and nearby Brohard Park provide picnic areas, fishing piers, and public access for families and visitors.

Golf & Recreation: The region boasts nearby championship golf courses, tennis clubs, and wellness facilities, complementing the outdoor-focused lifestyle of Casey Key and Nokomis residents.

Dining & Shopping: Nokomis and nearby Venice provide boutique shopping, art galleries, fresh seafood restaurants, and cozy cafes. From casual waterfront dining to fine Gulf Coast cuisine, the area appeals to every taste.

Waterfront Lifestyle: Many properties feature private docks, boat lifts, and marina access, making the area a haven for boating enthusiasts and water sports lovers.

Architectural Styles & Home Features

Casey Key and Nokomis homes display a variety of architectural styles, including Mediterranean-inspired villas, coastal contemporary estates, and Old Florida-style cottages. Residences often feature open floor plans, expansive terraces, pools, hurricane-resistant construction, and luxury finishes designed to maximize Gulf and canal views.

Market Trends & Real Estate Tips

Inventory: Limited developable land and high demand make Casey Key and Nokomis real estate a scarce commodity.

Appreciation: Historically, properties in this region have maintained strong long-term value due to exclusivity, waterfront access, and low-density development.

Investment Potential: Seasonal rental demand is strong, making vacation homes an attractive source of income.

Local Expertise: Partnering with a Sarasota-area real estate professional ensures insight into off-market listings, seasonal pricing, and investment strategies.

Nearby Communities & Comparisons

Casey Key and Nokomis offer a more serene and private lifestyle compared to Lido Key or Longboat Key. While Lido Key focuses on St. Armands Circle and Longboat Key emphasizes golf and gated estates, Casey Key combines pristine beaches, canal-front living, and an intimate island experience ideal for buyers seeking tranquility and coastal elegance.

Experience Luxury Coastal Living on Casey Key & Nokomis

From sunrise walks along the Gulf to sunset cruises on Sarasota Bay, living on Casey Key and in Nokomis offers an unparalleled combination of privacy, natural beauty, and coastal sophistication. Luxury real estate, boating access, and proximity to Sarasota and Venice make this area one of Florida’s most desirable Gulf Coast destinations.

Explore elevated living on Casey Key & Nokomis — where luxury, location, and lifestyle meet seamlessly. I am Sarasota’s leading Sales expert. Contact me at 941.281.5472 or email lisa@sarasotaluxurycondos.com.

Available Properties in Casey Key

Address Price Bed / Bths Interior Space $sf WF / Pool MLS
2542 CASEY KEY ROAD
$11,950,000 5/5
5,414sf $2,207 Y / Y
3761 CASEY KEY ROAD
$9,750,000 3/3
3,489sf $2,794 Y / Y
3240 CASEY KEY ROAD
$6,400,000 5/4
5,765sf $1,110 Y / Y
612 LAUREL ROAD
$4,950,000 3/2
2,960sf $1,672 Y / Y
4678 SILENT CREEK WAY
$4,795,000 5/3
4,914sf $976 Y / Y
621 CASEY KEY ROAD
$4,750,000 2/1
1,140sf $4,167 Y / Y
1620 CASEY KEY ROAD
$3,650,000 2/3
1,858sf $1,964 Y / N
1620 CASEY KEY ROAD
$3,650,000 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
3780 CUTLASS BAYOU ROAD
$3,650,000 4/4
3,102sf $1,177 Y / Y
919 KEY WAY
$2,699,000 6/5
3,497sf $772 Y / Y
2414 BAYSHORE ROAD
$2,650,000 3/3
3,713sf $714 N / N
504 BAY POINT AVENUE
$2,599,000 4/3
4,769sf $545 N / Y
212 SUNRISE DRIVE
$2,450,000 3/2
2,373sf $1,032 Y / Y
1210 CASEY KEY ROAD
$1,999,000 3/3
2,784sf $718 N / Y
922 CASEY COVE DRIVE
$1,995,000 2/2
1,722sf $1,159 Y / Y
216 SUNRISE DRIVE
$1,900,000 3/2
1,689sf $1,125 Y / N
3708 SANDSPUR LANE
$1,795,000 4/2
2,616sf $686 N / Y
0 BAYVIEW PARKWAY
$1,789,999 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
221 LYCHEE ROAD
$1,650,000 5/3
4,166sf $396 Y / Y
1210 TWIN LAKES AVENUE
$1,500,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
405 BAY POINT AVENUE
$1,495,000 6/5
3,716sf $402 N / N
1461 BAYSHORE ROAD
$1,450,000 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
617 MARAVIYA BOULEVARD
$1,350,000 3/3
2,779sf $486 Y / Y
14582 BALD CYPRESS WAY
$1,350,000 3/3
2,857sf $473 Y / Y
4020 CASEY KEY ROAD
$1,350,000 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
1669 LUGANO CIRCLE
$1,239,000 5/4
3,759sf $330 N / Y
1154 KINGS WAY DRIVE
$1,175,000 3/3
2,947sf $399 Y / Y
286 PESARO DRIVE
$1,149,900 3/3
3,136sf $367 N / Y
1671 LUGANO CIRCLE
$1,019,999 5/3
3,899sf $262 N / N
1684 LUGANO CIRCLE
$995,000 4/4
3,174sf $313 N / Y
289 VILLORESI BOULEVARD
$974,900 3/4
3,273sf $298 Y / N
2067 TOCOBAGA LANE
$974,900 3/3
3,466sf $281 N / Y
5970 TALON PRESERVE DRIVE
$949,900 3/2
2,092sf $454 Y / Y
617 MISTIFLOWER CIRCLE
$939,000 4/3
2,808sf $334 N / Y
1753 LUGANO CIRCLE
$919,999 5/5
3,745sf $246 N / N
208 CORELLI DRIVE
$850,000 3/3
2,635sf $323 N / Y
881 PINTO CIRCLE
$850,000 3/2
2,297sf $370 N / N
416 ALBERATA WAY
$849,999 5/5
3,745sf $227 N / N
5880 SEMOLINO STREET
$848,600 3/3
2,340sf $363 N / Y
2181 CALUSA LAKES BOULEVARD
$839,000 3/3
2,938sf $286 N / Y
6319 CRESTED EAGLE LANE
$827,500 3/2
1,640sf $505 N / Y
1109 DELACROIX CIRCLE
$824,900 4/3
3,169sf $260 N / Y
1645 LUGANO CIRCLE
$799,999 3/3
2,306sf $347 N / N
437 ALBERATA WAY
$799,900 5/4
3,393sf $236 Y / N
185 MEDICI TERRACE
$785,000 4/3
2,562sf $306 N / Y
2120 MUSKOGEE TRAIL
$769,000 3/2
2,701sf $285 Y / Y
751 ARABIAN CIRCLE
$740,000 5/3
2,164sf $342 N / N
15360 ISLA PALMA LANE
$729,000 4/3
2,582sf $282 N / Y
174 VERAZA COURT
$725,000 3/2
2,214sf $327 N / Y
424 ALBERATA WAY
$719,999 4/2
2,851sf $253 N / N
155 TOSCAVILLA BOULEVARD
$719,000 4/3
2,340sf $307 N / Y
5617 SCARLOTTI STREET
$700,000 3/3
2,323sf $301 N / Y
2075 VARESE STREET
$699,999 3/2
2,337sf $300 N / N
408 TORTUGA DRIVE
$699,999 3/2
2,310sf $303 N / N
282 HOLLY BANK AVENUE
$699,900 4/3
2,713sf $258 N / N
1503 MARLIN STREET
$695,000 2/2
2,191sf $317 Y / Y
289 HOLLY BANK AVENUE
$689,900 4/3
3,024sf $228 N / N
1620 MISSION VALLEY BOULEVARD
$689,500 3/2
2,248sf $307 N / Y
1603 PECAN STREET
$689,000 4/3
2,605sf $264 N / Y
1956 WHITE FEATHER LANE
$680,000 3/2
2,362sf $288 N / Y
7028 FOXBORO WAY
$674,979 5/4
3,053sf $221 N / N
294 HOLLY BANK AVENUE
$669,900 4/3
2,713sf $247 N / N
144 VISTERA BOULEVARD
$649,999 4/3
2,628sf $247 N / N
136 VISTERA BOULEVARD
$649,999 4/3
2,628sf $247 N / N
2331 MISSION VALLEY BOULEVARD
$649,700 3/3
2,056sf $316 N / Y
6933 PRAIRIE OAK WAY
$649,688 4/3
2,721sf $239 N / N
5548 SENTIERO DRIVE
$645,000 3/2
1,944sf $332 Y / N
228 MARAVIYA BOULEVARD
$644,900 3/2
1,996sf $323 Y / N
6917 PRAIRIE OAK WAY
$642,874 4/3
2,394sf $269 N / N
6929 PRAIRIE OAK WAY
$642,084 4/3
2,394sf $268 N / N
290 HOLLY BANK AVENUE
$639,900 3/3
2,200sf $291 N / N
516 CASAS BONITAS WAY
$635,000 3/2
1,737sf $366 N / Y
1505 MORGAN STREET
$635,000 2/2
1,335sf $476 N / Y
413 SIGNORELLI DRIVE
$635,000 3/2
2,645sf $240 Y / Y
2025 WHITE FEATHER LANE
$630,000 3/2
2,477sf $254 N / Y
15537 FOXTAIL LANE
$627,500 4/3
2,394sf $262 N / N
1305 SORRENTO WOODS BOULEVARD
$625,000 3/2
2,300sf $272 Y / Y
212 GIOTTO DRIVE
$625,000 3/2
2,384sf $262 N / Y
165 PALAZZO COURT
$624,900 3/2
2,135sf $293 Y / Y
7024 FOXBORO WAY
$624,764 5/4
3,053sf $205 N / N
100 MATISSE CIRCLE
$620,000 3/2
1,995sf $311 N / Y
302 DEGAS DRIVE
$615,000 3/2
1,715sf $359 N / Y
15069 SHADY PALMS LANE
$615,000 5/3
2,459sf $250 N / N
119 POMPANO LANE
$615,000 3/1
1,643sf $374 Y / N
152 VISTERA BOULEVARD
$599,999 3/2
2,337sf $257 N / N
383 SUN CHASER DRIVE
$599,900 4/3
2,517sf $238 N / N
6913 PRAIRIE OAK WAY
$599,688 4/3
2,721sf $220 N / N
7057 FOXBORO WAY
$599,164 4/3
2,600sf $230 N / N
5659 EQUATOR COURT
$599,000 4/2
2,473sf $242 N / N
BAYVIEW DRIVE
$599,000 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
302 DONA DRIVE
$595,000 2/3
2,032sf $293 Y / N
286 DAYLILY BOULEVARD
$589,900 3/2
2,093sf $282 Y / N
620 NASTURTIUM COURT
$585,000 4/2
2,333sf $251 N / N
352 TOSCAVILLA BOULEVARD
$585,000 4/3
2,431sf $241 N / N
140 VISTERA BOULEVARD
$579,999 3/2
2,337sf $248 N / N
405 BAYSIDE LANE
$579,000 3/2
2,073sf $279 N / Y
312 WINFIELD WAY
$575,000 3/1
1,746sf $329 Y / Y
625 SANDPIPER LANE
$575,000 2/2
1,494sf $385 Y / Y
326 HOLLY BANK AVENUE
$574,900 3/3
2,200sf $261 N / N
7045 FOXBORO WAY
$574,499 4/3
2,394sf $240 N / N
15525 FOXTAIL LANE
$574,344 4/3
2,600sf $221 N / N
7012 FOXBORO WAY
$570,951 4/3
2,582sf $221 N / Y
7008 FOXBORO WAY
$561,021 4/3
2,582sf $217 N / Y
6323 CRESTED EAGLE LANE
$560,000 2/2
1,408sf $398 N / Y
2102 TEQUESTA TRAIL
$557,000 3/2
1,932sf $288 N / Y
600 ALLORA AVENUE
$554,990 5/3
2,968sf $187 N / N
506 SUN CHASER DRIVE
$550,000 5/3
2,830sf $194 Y / N
440 LYCHEE ROAD
$550,000 3/2
1,549sf $355 N / Y
15336 ISLA PALMA LANE
$550,000 4/3
2,177sf $253 N / N
807 LUCILLE AVENUE
$550,000 3/2
1,622sf $339 N / N
185 SAVONA WAY
$549,000 2/2
1,994sf $275 N / N
15532 FOXTAIL LANE
$548,559 4/3
2,394sf $229 N / N
293 DAYLILY BOULEVARD
$546,000 4/2
2,333sf $234 N / N
161 VISTERA BOULEVARD
$539,999 3/2
1,763sf $306 N / N
117 SHADY EDGE LOOP
$539,980 5/3
2,830sf $191 N / N
520 MARAVIYA BOULEVARD
$539,900 3/2
2,214sf $244 N / N
215 CASSANO DRIVE
$535,000 3/2
1,764sf $303 Y / N
156 SHADY EDGE LOOP
$529,900 5/3
2,574sf $206 N / N
5853 SEMOLINO STREET
$528,000 2/2
1,678sf $315 N / N
400 TORTUGA DRIVE
$524,999 3/2
2,009sf $261 N / Y
6932 PRAIRIE OAK WAY
$524,586 4/3
2,862sf $183 N / Y
1053 DERIAN PLACE
$524,000 3/2
1,718sf $305 N / Y
116 SHADY EDGE LOOP
$521,150 5/3
2,574sf $202 N / N
108 MARAVIYA BOULEVARD
$519,000 3/2
1,806sf $287 N / Y
5749 SEMOLINO STREET
$515,000 2/2
1,678sf $307 Y / N
188 DAYLILY BOULEVARD
$512,000 4/2
1,888sf $271 Y / N
121 SHADY EDGE LOOP
$505,000 4/3
2,574sf $196 N / N
2087 TIMUCUA TRAIL
$505,000 3/2
2,296sf $220 Y / N
128 AVENS DR
$499,999 3/3
2,105sf $238 N / N
6962 MINNEOLA COURT
$499,990 3/2
2,088sf $239 N / N
6990 MINNEOLA COURT
$499,990 3/2
2,088sf $239 N / N
254 HOLLY BANK AVENUE
$499,900 0/
N/A N/A N / N
223 RAVENNA STREET
$499,900 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
288 SOLIERA STREET
$499,900 3/2
1,988sf $251 N / N
106 GULF AVENUE
$499,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
601 HAMLIN STREET
$499,000 3/2
1,830sf $273 N / Y
152 LAZY SHORE DRIVE
$495,000 3/2
1,704sf $290 N / Y
132 SUN CHASER DRIVE
$493,410 4/3
2,190sf $225 N / N
2320 LAKE SHORE DRIVE
$490,000 2/2
1,582sf $310 Y / Y
131 DEGAS DRIVE
$489,900 3/2
2,247sf $218 N / Y
1050 BLUFFWOOD DRIVE
$489,000 3/2
1,984sf $246 N / N
192 SOLIERA STREET
$489,000 3/2
1,427sf $343 N / Y
510 BUENA VISTA DRIVE
$479,999 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
602 PORTIA STREET
$479,900 2/2
2,016sf $238 Y / N
131 MARAVIYA BOULEVARD
$474,900 3/2
1,984sf $239 N / N
333 POTENZA LOOP
$465,990 3/2
1,768sf $264 N / N
345 POTENZA LOOP
$459,990 3/2
1,764sf $261 N / N
1051 BRADBERRY DRIVE
$459,000 3/2
1,984sf $231 Y / N
209 PALM AVENUE
$459,000 3/3
1,920sf $239 N / N
333 ALTAMURA CIRCLE
$457,990 3/2
1,533sf $299 N / N
223 ROBERTS ROAD
$450,000 2/2
1,375sf $327 N / N
0 LAUREL WOODS DRIVE
$450,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
0 TWIN LAKES AVENUE
$450,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
328 VISTERA BOULEVARD
$449,990 3/2
2,211sf $204 N / N
120 VENTOSA PLACE
$449,000 3/2
1,984sf $226 N / N
129 TREVISO COURT
$445,000 3/2
1,484sf $300 Y / N
128 SUN CHASER DRIVE
$444,830 3/2
1,654sf $269 N / N
105 OUTBACK HIDEAWAY AVENUE
$439,080 4/2
2,340sf $188 N / N
360 LAZY SHORE DRIVE
$430,640 4/2
2,168sf $199 N / N
706 QUAIL COURT
$425,000 2/2
1,011sf $420 Y / N
184 DAYLILY BOULEVARD
$425,000 3/2
1,466sf $290 N / N
1015 BLUFFWOOD DRIVE
$425,000 3/2
1,806sf $235 N / N
2400 PINE COURT
$419,990 2/2
1,467sf $286 N / Y
113 MOSCATA WAY
$419,000 3/2
1,614sf $260 N / N
0 SORRENTO PLACE
$419,000 3/2
1,399sf $299 N / N
413 PAMETO ROAD
$409,000 2/2
1,379sf $297 N / N
308 SOLIERA STREET
$399,000 3/2
1,816sf $220 N / N
216 HIBISCUS STREET
$399,000 3/2
1,457sf $274 N / N
514 BAYVIEW PARKWAY
$399,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
217 CHARLES DRIVE
$395,000 2/2
993sf $398 N / N
116 AVENS DRIVE
$390,000 3/2
1,775sf $220 N / N
0 ROBERTS RD. ROAD
$389,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
120 AVENIDA DE BAHA
$385,000 3/2
1,450sf $266 N / N
120 MOSCATA WAY
$384,900 2/2
1,544sf $249 N / N
108 CANOE BEND AVENUE
$380,040 3/2
1,483sf $256 N / N
510 DONA DRIVE
$379,900 2/2
1,304sf $291 N / Y
2600 PALMETTO STREET
$379,000 2/2
1,540sf $246 N / N
116 AVENIDA LA PALMA
$379,000 2/2
1,246sf $304 N / N
119 VAN DYCK DRIVE
$374,999 3/2
1,955sf $192 N / N
337 CHANDLER ROAD
$374,900 3/2
1,650sf $227 N / N
2294 HARRIER WAY
$369,000 2/2
1,897sf $195 N / N
2165 LAKEWOOD DRIVE
$360,000 2/2
1,556sf $231 Y / N
161 CANOE BEND AVENUE
$355,000 3/2
1,269sf $280 N / N
231 NIPPINO TRAIL E
$339,000 4/2
2,214sf $153 N / N
513 PINE ROAD
$325,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
OAK STREET
$299,000 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
603 CHURCH STREET
$294,900 3/2
912sf $323 N / N
808 SUNCREST DRIVE
$294,500 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
0 LA PALMA
$260,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
COLONIAL BAY DRIVE
$260,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
216 PAVONIA ROAD
$245,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
44 CROWN POINT DRIVE
$225,000 2/2
720sf $312 N / N
220 MOUNT PLEASANT ROAD
$207,500 2/2
1,074sf $193 N / N
321 RAVENNA STREET
$199,000 0/
N/A N/A Y / N
204 CROWN POINT DRIVE
$185,000 2/1
740sf $250 N / N
206 RAVENNA STREET
$185,000 2/1
700sf $264 N / N
105 COLONIA LANE
$185,000 2/2
1,116sf $166 N / N
EDMONDSON ROAD
$160,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
6 LAFITTE DRIVE
$159,900 2/2
1,318sf $121 N / N
125 BROOKSHIRE DRIVE
$149,000 1/1
730sf $204 Y / N
COLONIA LANE
$149,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
110 VERONA STREET
$137,000 2/1
600sf $228 N / N
DONA WAY
$135,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
40 LAFITTE DRIVE
$129,900 2/2
984sf $132 N / N
237 BAINBRIDGE DRIVE
$125,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
OLD TRAIL DRIVE
$120,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
610 COQUINA COURT
$98,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
1431 COLONIA LANE
$95,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
OLIVE AVENUE
$90,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
0 RAVENNA STREET
$80,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
0 ORANGE GROVE
$70,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N
103 IRENE STREET
$64,000 0/
N/A N/A N / N

Casey Key Location